Snow melting mat, salt or heat cable?

There are several ways to keep a step or path free of ice, and they differ more than the shelf suggests. Salt is cheap and quick but has limits, a mat covers only where it lies, and the permanent systems belong to a building project.

Four ways to keep a path clear

Shoveling comes first for almost everyone, and what follows it decides whether the path stays safe. The choices below differ in where they work, how cold they cope with and who puts them in.

MethodSetupCold limitSide effects
Rock saltSpread by handWorks poorly below about 15 °FCan damage concrete, plants and paws
Other de-icersSpread by handRead the bagRead the bag
Heated matLay it down, plug it inHeatTrak walkway listings say down to -8 °FUses power, covers only its own area
Heat cableFixed in placeDepends on the productUses power, needs planning
Embedded systemElectrician, under new pavingDesigned per jobBuilding project, not a purchase

Rock salt and other de-icers

Rock salt is sodium chloride, the bag most people grab first. It works in mild cold, but it struggles once temperatures sink below about 15 °F, which is when ice is at its worst.

Salt also leaves a bill of its own. It can damage concrete and harm the plants along the path, and it is hard on pets’ paws as well.

Other de-icers are sold as gentler or colder-working blends. Our sources give no figures for them, so read the label on each bag for its temperature range and any warnings about concrete, plants and pets.

On composite decking, a stray de-icer is one more reason to read the label. The guide to mats on wood, composite and concrete covers what each surface needs instead.

Heated snow melting mats

A mat lies on top of the step or path and turns electricity into heat. Per HeatTrak, its mats handle up to 2 in of snowfall an hour while the top stays about 40 °F warmer than the surrounding air, and the walkway listings claim they work down to -8 °F.

Nothing gets dug, wired in or poured. You plug the mat into an outdoor GFCI outlet wearing an in-use cover, or into the HeatTrak Power Unit for its walkway and stair mats, and switch it on before the snow starts.

The limit is coverage. A mat clears only the strip it covers, so it suits steps, a door and a short walk rather than a whole driveway, and how heated mats melt snow explains why.

For a plug-in option that needs no separate unit, the Toriexon 20 × 60 in mat goes straight into an outdoor GFCI outlet. It has few owner reviews so far, while the HeatTrak walkway mat is the most-reviewed snow melting mat on Amazon.

What a mat costs to run

HeatTrak puts the running cost at about 18 cents an hour for a typical set, by its own estimate. Your figure depends on how many mats you run and on your electricity rate.

The arithmetic is simple to do yourself. A 300 W walkway mat running for 10 hours uses 3 kWh, so multiply that by the rate on your power bill, and see the guide to running costs for more cases.

Salt costs money too, bag after bag, but it costs nothing to leave in the garage. A mat costs a little every hour it runs, so the habit of switching it off after the storm matters.

Heat cable

Heat cable is a heating wire rather than a mat. It is fixed along a surface or set into one, and once a cable is buried it becomes an installation job instead of something you unpack and plug in.

Our sources give no cold ratings or power figures for heat cable, so we keep the comparison general. Treat it as a planned, semi-permanent option and follow its maker’s instructions to the letter.

For a few steps or one walk, a cable is more planning than the problem calls for. A mat does the same job on the same strip and goes back in the shed in spring.

Embedded snow-melt systems

An embedded system puts heating cable or tubing under the driveway or walk itself. Electricians install these under new paving, so they make sense when you are pouring a new driveway anyway, not as a fix for the one you have.

Once in, such a system clears the whole paved area rather than a mat-sized strip. It also needs its own circuit and design work, so it is a decision for a contractor and an electrician, not a shopping trip.

Which one fits your home

  • A few steps and a door, with an outdoor outlet nearby, suit a mat or a chain of treads
  • A long driveway being repaved is the case for an embedded system
  • A short walk in mild winters can get by with a shovel and occasional salt
  • Composite decking rules out guesswork, so read the label or use a mat with a barrier
  • Deep, regular cold below 15 °F favors heat over salt

Many homes mix methods, with a mat on the steps and a shovel for the drive. Just keep salt and metal tools off the mats themselves, since shovels and ice chippers are banned on a mat.

No method keeps up with every storm. In very heavy snowfall or deep cold even a heated mat falls behind, and when a mat falls behind explains what to expect and how to help it.

Choosing a mat

If a mat suits your steps, our snow melting mat buying guide compares the five we cover, and the buying advice on the home page walks through sizes and outlets. The comparison table puts their power draw side by side.

Brand matters more with mats than with a bag of salt, because you plug them in for years. The guide to snow melting mat brands looks at who stands behind each one.

If you are ready to stop salting the steps

The HeatTrak walkway mat is the most-reviewed snow melting mat on Amazon and chains to stair treads on one Power Unit. It replaces salt on the strip it covers, as long as you add the unit it needs.

Questions and answers

More questions about mats, salt and heat cable

Is a heated mat better than rock salt?

On the strip it covers, a mat avoids the drawbacks of salt, which stops working well below about 15 °F and can damage concrete, plants and pets’ paws. Salt covers any area you throw it on, while a mat clears only where it lies.

What does a snow melting mat cost to run compared with salt?

By HeatTrak’s own figure, a typical set runs at about 18 cents an hour. You can work out your own figure from watts times hours divided by 1,000, then multiply the kWh by the rate on your power bill.

What is the difference between heat cable and a heated mat?

Heat cable is a heating wire fixed along or into a surface, which makes it a planned installation. A mat lies loose on top, plugs into a GFCI outdoor outlet and comes up in spring.

Can I install an embedded snow-melt system under my existing driveway?

Embedded systems go under new paving and are installed by electricians, so they suit a driveway that is being poured or replaced. For an existing path, a mat on top is the practical choice.

Can I use salt on top of a snow melting mat?

There is no need, since the mat melts the snow itself. Keep salt off composite decking unless its label allows it, and never use a shovel or ice chipper on the mat.